How can this be?
There is no shortage of commitments, in the Sustainable Development Goals (SDG), the international community has committed to eliminating child labour by 2025. The UK, Australia, France and the Netherlands have passed legislation requiring companies to address child labour in their supply chains. Other countries plan to follow suit.
Turning commitments into tangible results
The causes of child labour are multi-faceted. The major factor, however, remains economic. As long as families are not able to earn a decent living from their crops, and youth lack decent employment opportunities, the SDG target will remain difficult to achieve.
Fairtrade works to enable farmers and workers to earn a decent living. Our standards have always strictly prohibited child labour and forced labour. But over time we realised that standards and auditing alone would not solve this deeply rooted problem.
Ten years ago, we began to adapt our approach. In 2009, we became the first certification scheme to implement a rights-based approach to child labour elimination, ensuring that child protection is a key outcome. We spoke to thousands of children and young people in Fairtrade producer communities about their views and needs. And we collaborated with NGOs, child rights organizations, academic institutions, businesses and governments to seek solutions that would bring together all actors in the supply chain.
Looking back, four key lessons stand out
1. Ending child labour on farms is not enough
The theme for this year’s World Day Against Child Labour is ‘Children shouldn’t work in fields, but on dreams’. This is certainly a valid call. But we also need to look beyond the fields. During a recent workshop in the Philippines, a young daughter of a sugar cane farmer shared that ‘gender-based violence is everywhere in my community’. Children in and around Fairtrade farming communities tell us that they have experienced abuse in their homes, villages, and schools. We cannot tackle child labour in agriculture without addressing the wider causes of abuse and violence against children and young people.
Fairtrade’s approach encompasses the whole community where the farmers, workers and their families live. Hence the name: Youth Inclusive Community Based Monitoring and Remediation (YICBMR) on Child Labour.
2. Young people and their communities must be at the heart of any solution
In our youth inclusive approach, children and youth identify risks to their wellbeing, map where they feel safe and unsafe, including reasons for these and together with adults from the community, design preventive projects to enhance children’s wellbeing and development.
‘Fairtrade’s YICBMR approach really reveals the many potential causes of child rights violations in the communities and empowers the community to take decisions to address them,’ says Franklina Tweneboah Koduah, a Young Leader at a cocoa co-operative in Ghana. ‘It has made community members more open to share their experience rather than trying to be on the defensive and cover up child labour and other violation cases.’
Producer organisations in more than ten countries have piloted this approach, engaging local community members, schools and district level governments to address not only child labour, but forced labour and gender-based violence issues. After the workshop in the Philippines, a sugar cane co-operative there has embraced the YICBMR approach, aiming to stop gender-based violence in their communities. A sugar co-operative in Fiji has also recently chosen to apply the method to address both child labour and forced adult labour, recognising that these unacceptable labour practices are linked, particularly in countries with severe labour shortages. Producer organisations in Belize and India, among others, continue to implement the YICBMR approach to address protection risk issues.
3. We must work with governments to ensure children’s long-term safety
If child labour is detected on Fairtrade farms or plantations, our first priority is to act to protect the children and vulnerable individuals affected. Fairtrade producer organisations have reported hundreds of cases of child labour, human trafficking and gender-based violence.
Severe cases are reported confidentially to governments for follow up. This has led to long-standing human traffickers being arrested and impacted children being able to make a fresh start. But unfortunately, this is not always the case.
Our experience has shown that even if the children are removed from the place of work, they aren’t always safe. They may return to the same work or choose illicit and hidden ways of earning money to survive. Children from single-parent households often take on multiple domestic chores, or care for siblings or grandparents instead. As one 16-year-old boy told us, ‘I was working and making some money so I could support my schooling. My parents cannot afford to buy me books or shoes. Now I am still working caring for the chickens and goats at home but making no money and cannot go to school.’
Fairtrade is talking to the ILO, governments, and supply chain actors to support youth innovation projects in agriculture for 16 to 18 year-olds withdrawn from hazardous labour. Such projects would enable us to understand what alternative income generation projects are most suitable for them.
4. Everyone in the supply chain needs to collaborate
In addition to our collaboration with NGOs and governments, we connect companies with producers, to invest directly in mitigating child labour in the communities from which they purchase Fairtrade commodities. The voluntary best practice section of Fairtrade’s Trader Standard also encourages this. This has brought some positive partnerships and results – now more companies need to follow suit.
We can all play a part here. All of us have the power to drive change through our purchasing choices. Creating more demand for sustainable and ethically produced products will push companies to do better, as will advocacy and regulations.
Children and young people, no matter where they are, dream of a life free from violence and abuse. This dream is meant to be a basic human right. Let’s not wait another century, or even another decade, to make it a reality.